Why Do Bills Of Revenue Originate In The House?

The clause was included as part of a negotiated settlement between the major and minor states. Minority-majority states, which would be overrepresented in the Senate, would relinquish authority over money legislation to the House of Representatives, where states with bigger populations would have greater influence.

Where do bills for raising revenue originate?

According to the Constitution, ″All bills for obtaining revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives; however, the Senate may propose or concur in Amendment to such bills as it does with other bills.″

Why do most bills originate in the House of Representatives?

According to the Constitution, ″All legislation for producing revenue should originate in the House of Representatives; however, the Senate may propose or concur with modifications to such laws, as it does with other Bills.″ To put in place an institutional safeguard to protect citizens from onerous taxing practices.

Why don’t revenue bills come from Congress?

For starters, many revenue legislation have their conceptual origins in the Treasury Department rather than in the House of Representatives. Elbridge Gerry’s concerns were well-founded, as well, because the Senate’s authority to alter is usually recognized in practice to be so extensive that the Senate can completely rewrite the wording of a law that officially originated in the House.

Where do appropriation bills come from in Congress?

  • Traditionally, appropriation bills begin in the House of Representatives and then move to the Senate.
  • In addition, the Constitution stipulates that the ″Senate may propose or concur with Amendments on Revenue Legislation, as it does on other Bills,″ which refers to revenue bills.
  • The Senate and the House each create and evaluate their own appropriation bills, just as they do with revenue legislation.
You might be interested:  FAQ: When does elena turn her humanity on?

Where do bills for raising revenue originate?

According to the Constitution, ″All bills for obtaining revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives; however, the Senate may propose or concur in Amendment to such bills as it does with other bills.″

Why do most bills originate in the House of Representatives?

According to the Constitution, ″All legislation for producing revenue should originate in the House of Representatives; however, the Senate may propose or concur with modifications to such laws, as it does with other Bills.″ To put in place an institutional safeguard to protect citizens from onerous taxing practices.

Why don’t revenue bills come from Congress?

For starters, many revenue legislation have their conceptual origins in the Treasury Department rather than in the House of Representatives. Elbridge Gerry’s concerns were well-founded, as well, because the Senate’s authority to alter is usually recognized in practice to be so extensive that the Senate can completely rewrite the wording of a law that officially originated in the House.

How does the Senate pass a bill to raise revenue?

As a practical issue, the Senate originates ″bills to produce money″ in reliance on the Rulemaking Clause of the Constitution. Using the ″gut and replace″ procedure, the Senate takes a revenue measure that was first introduced in the House, eliminates all of the House text while keeping the House-designated bill number, and replaces the language with Senate language.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *